This article was produced in collaboration with Virginia Quarterly Review. It may not be reproduced without express permission from FERN. If you are interested in republishing or reposting this article, please contact info@thefern.org.
On a hot summer day in 1948, a three-mile-long parade wound through Georgetown, Delaware, complete with flags and floats and bands. The party wasn’t for the Fourth of July, nor the small town’s colonial history, nor any lingering World War II celebrations. It was for chicken.
In the auditorium of the town’s high school, the sponsors had just announced the results of a nationwide competition to breed a better bird: the Chicken of Tomorrow contest. Even in the 1940s, poultry was a huge industry in America, though most of its revenue was from eggs, not the bird itself. Chickens for eating, known as broilers, were an afterthought. They were grown to be sold as meat but came from the same breeds as laying hens, which meant they were undermuscled, not big enough to make a meal, and not appealing to people who had just regained access to steaks and bacon after years of rationing.
The largest supermarket chain in the US, the Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company (later, A&P Supermarket), had noticed the problem at its own meat counters. Its leadership believed that a lucrative market was waiting for whoever could tilt consumer interest toward chicken. But before that could happen, chickens themselves would have to change. A&P proposed the Chicken of Tomorrow contest and persuaded the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) to be its sponsor. It courted breeders and growers, posting a $5,000 prize. The Saturday Evening Post conjured the goal for its readers: “One bird chunky enough for the whole family—a chicken with breast meat so thick you could carve it into steaks, with drumsticks that contain a minimum of bone buried in layers of juicy dark meat, all costing less instead of more.”
Contestants who thought they could build a better bird were given a year to raise their prototype and two more years to prove that their achievement could pass its characteristics down through several generations. State and regional evaluations winnowed 1,500 participants down to forty finalists, and on March 1, 1948, each finalist shipped fertilized eggs to the University of Delaware campus in Georgetown so that every chick could be raised under identical conditions. In June, the prize went to a California breeder named Charles Vantress. He went home with the $5,000 check and created an industry.
Nearly eighty years later, most of the billions of chickens grown and eaten every year come from a narrow set of secret genetic recipes that originated in the winning crossbreeds of 1948. The Chicken of Tomorrow contest fulfilled its promise: It produced an animal that everyone wanted to eat.
It took a while for anyone to consider the implications of that for chickens, much less launch a reform movement to reverse its worst effects.
Before the Chicken of Tomorrow, chickens were standard bred, what we’d now call heritage breeds: Plymouth Rocks or Leghorns or Cornish, chosen by farmers to suit farm types or production goals. After the contest, they were replaced by hybrids. Vantress’s winning chicken was a cross between a Cornish and a New Hampshire Red, known for its upright bearing and deep, rounded breast. He won not because the judges liked the look of his bird—the runner-up, Henry Saglio of Arbor Acres, actually took the prize for “carcass characteristics”—but because his bird put on weight rapidly, a process they called “feed efficiency.” The bird-raising time allotted to the contest’s finalists was twelve weeks and two days, and in that time, Vantress’s winning birds grew to weigh between three and four pounds.
Researchers have repeatedly found that fast, unbalanced weight gain leads to failing hearts, weak legs, vulnerability to diseases, and a lack of interest in moving around.
Modern chickens are the descendants of those birds that Vantress and Saglio produced almost eighty years ago. Decades of precision crossbreeding by companies that came later revved up Vantress’s feed efficiency and Saglio’s breast-heavy conformation, producing birds with ferocious appetites that reach an average of 6.6 pounds in forty-seven days—twice the weight, in about half the time—and will keep getting bigger if allowed to live longer. Those gains come with downsides, of course. Researchers have repeatedly found that fast, unbalanced weight gain leads to failing hearts, weak legs, vulnerability to diseases, and a lack of interest in moving around. In the 1990s, when broilers weren’t nearly as big as they are today, renowned British animal scientist John Webster observed that about one quarter of the heavy strains suffer from chronic pain for about one third of their lives.
For most of the industry’s biggest actors, this was an acceptable cost. Chicken is, after all, the most popular meat in nearly every industrialized country and is on its way to passing pork as the most consumed meat on the planet. Humans grow so much chicken globally that the biomass of chickens exceeds that of all the world’s other bird species put together. (Scientists have proposed that the eventual fossil record of this age will be a layer of chicken bones.) In the US alone, poultry producers raise more than nine billion birds per year.
That so many chickens live their short lives in such discomfort has long been obvious to animal advocates, but they have struggled to convey that message to the public. While many more consumers today have at least some awareness of the plight of industrial chickens than did thirty years ago, the image of a picturesque red barn nestled in rolling green fields has an enduring hold on our imagination, though it does not portray how must animals are raised. “There’s been recent polling on this: Consumers know effectively nothing about genetics,” says Andrew deCoriolis, executive director at Farm Forward, an advocacy group opposed to industrial-scale animal production that funds research into animal agriculture. “There really is just no market awareness about chickens and how they are raised.”
About a decade ago, animal advocates decided to try to inform cooks and consumers about the degree to which chickens had been grossly transformed and to persuade them of the benefits of changing birds again. Their plan was not to take chickens back to the heritage breeds that dominated before 1948, but rather to get the industry to switch to other hybrids that put on flesh more slowly, with a more balanced shape and without the painful damages of broilers’ explosive growth.
It was a bold goal because it threatened to introduce variability into chicken production, and the modern poultry industry is founded on absolute predictability. Fuel orders, feed distribution, even the design of slaughter apparatuses and processing lines rely on every chicken—the Cobb 500 descended from Vantress’s birds and the Ross 308 that traces back to Saglio’s—growing to the same size at the same rate.
A protest in London against a ruling allowing the use of fast-growing, genetically selected chickens on farms in England. AP Photo/Kin Cheung
Still, the advocates—members of the welfare organizations Compassion in World Farming, The Humane League, Mercy for Animals, and others—thought they had momentum on their side. They were inspired by a recent, compelling success: winning the battle to get cages out of the business of producing eggs.
In the early 2000s, almost all the eggs produced in the US—and 100 percent of those used by food processors and big fast-food chains—came from hens packed so tightly in their enclosures that they couldn’t spread their wings. A few groups took that on as a cause. The campaign scored its first achievement in 2008, when California voters approved limits on confining farm animals. By 2016, McDonald’s, Walmart, and food-service giant Sodexo had all committed to switching to cage-free by the end of 2025. Today, the label for bestselling mayo Hellmann’s says, “Made with 100% cage-free eggs.”
“We are at almost 50 percent cage-free production in the US,” says Leah Garcés, a longtime animal-welfare advocate who is now global ambassador for Compassion in World Farming. “McDonald’s is 100 percent cage-free right now. If you go into McDonald’s and order a McMuffin, those are cage-free eggs.”
Campaigners believed that if companies and consumers endorsed change for laying hens, surely they would for meat chickens too. In 2016, a coalition of welfare organizations proposed the Better Chicken Commitment: a voluntary agreement to make specific improvements in raising practices for broilers, starting with giving birds more space and light, then adding barn features to provide them physical and mental stimulation and using more humane slaughter methods, and culminating in a switch to slower-growing breeds of birds. More than two hundred companies signed on, agreeing to meet deadlines for change that expire this year.
It seemed like a triumph, the beginning of the end of the Chicken of Tomorrow. But real change would prove harder to achieve.
In Europe, chicken welfare carved a different path. More than a decade after the Chicken of Tomorrow contest, welfare advocates there began asking what had been taken away from animals in pursuit of profit. In 1964, a British researcher named Ruth Harrison published Animal Machines, the first book to examine the living conditions of industrial farm animals. The book did for animal welfare what Silent Spring had done two years earlier for environmental destruction—igniting media coverage, spurring government investigations, and inspiring outraged advocacy campaigns. It led to a United Kingdom welfare organization articulating what would eventually be called “the Five Freedoms,” which establish ethical principles of animal husbandry, including that farm animals should be spared hunger and thirst, discomfort, pain, and fear, and be guaranteed enough space and company to express whatever behaviors are natural for their species.
Building on initial UK legislation from 1968, this framework triggered a cascade of baseline welfare protections for animals raised for food through European treaties in 1979, 1997, and 2007. (The US took a markedly different approach: Federal animal-welfare laws — from which chickens are exempted — govern only transport and slaughter, while just ten states have adopted measures that include bans on confinement practices.) Still, even Europe’s progressive treaties set only minimum welfare standards, and did nothing to prevent producers from raising the same sort of fast-growing birds that exist in the US.
But European consumers, governments, and eventually companies were more open to considering change. In 2007, the Dutch Society for the Protection of Animals introduced a tiered scoring system for chickens called Beter Leven (literally, “better life”) that required slower-growing birds as a basic condition. Five years later, an animal-advocacy organization called Wakker Dier launched an advertising campaign deriding the country’s supermarkets for selling plofkip, “exploding chicken,” a campaign so successful that after just three months one major food processor gave in and eliminated fast-growth chicken from its products.
In 2015, Germany created a similar system, overseen by a coalition that includes livestock slaughterhouses; Denmark followed in 2017 with a voluntary government-run label that requires slow-growth birds. That same year, European animal-welfare organizations also developed an EU version of the Better Chicken Commitment, which specified improving available space and light, reducing the density of birds in barns, and swapping conventional broiler breeds for sturdier birds that would put on weight more slowly and thus endure less pain.
Each system in each European country acknowledged that producing better birds—using slow-growth broilers and improving their living conditions—would be more expensive. And yet consumers embraced the products. Since 2024, for instance, all the fresh chicken sold by Dutch supermarket chains has been Beter Leven–labeled. In September this year, the Dutch ministry of agriculture asked parliament to agree to a ban on fast-growing breeds. And just a month later, Denmark’s minister for nature and animal welfare and several parties in the coalition government called for a similar ban.
In Germany, broilers of the slower-growing breed Hubbard 757 live in a house built to the specifications of the Dutch system called “Better Life 1 Star.” Photo by Sina Schuldt/picture alliance via Getty Images
With each change in a country’s market, it became easier for other countries to follow. In January 2026, the poultry industry in Norway, which produces about seventy million broilers per year, announced that it would voluntarily convert all its production to slower-growing birds by the end of next year.
To realize this historic shift in practice, animal-welfare groups first found a company that was willing to participate: Norsk Kylling (“Norwegian Chicken”), a wholly owned subsidiary of a grocery chain. “We said that the thing you need to do first is change the breed,” says Helle Haukvik, a veterinarian with the Norwegian Animal Protection Alliance. “The farmers said, ‘Oh, breed isn’t important because our management is so good, our mortality is already low, and it will be more expensive for the consumer.’ But they made the change, and then they started advertising on the basis of having better animal welfare and a better breed.”
Norsk Kylling switched its breed from the Ross 308 to a slower-growing bird in 2018 and now says it produces the same amount of meat while slaughtering 3.9 million fewer birds each year. It fulfilled all the conditions of the European Better Chicken Commitment in 2022.
The farmers at another major Norwegian producer, the cooperative Nortura, were skeptical, worrying that because better birds by definition take longer to grow, they would consume more food and water, a net negative for sustainability goals. Eventually, they came around too.
“It was a bit difficult at the start, but now they’re very happy,” says Kjersti Sørby, Nortura’s strategic project manager. “The farmers say the birds are pretty, more active, and you can see their personality. They are using less feed than we supposed, so actually it’s much better for the climate than we expected. And they use less water. They have way less disease as well.”
Ironically, the countries most responsible for the primacy of chicken—the United States, home of the Chicken of Tomorrow and also the chicken nugget, and the United Kingdom, the pioneer of animal advocacy—struggled the most with persuading the market to advance to better chicken.
Though many companies, including Burger King, Chipotle, and Shake Shack, signed the 2016 Better Chicken Commitment, some of the largest did not. McDonald’s, which years earlier had backed cage-free egg efforts, instead created its own eight-point welfare commitment for broilers. Those included improvements in lighting, the addition of enrichments—typically barn additions such as ramps and bales that allow chickens to exercise—and changes to slaughter methods. In 2025, McDonald’s announced that it had achieved these reforms, but the document reporting them contains no conclusions regarding breed change.
Whole Foods Market received media coverage in 2016, a year before it was bought by Amazon, for asking “all of its suppliers, even those raising large numbers of broilers indoors, to shift over to slower-growing breeds of chickens,” according to NPR. But the Whole Foods statement cited in that story is no longer live on the company website. In 2020, Whole Foods began publishing a “Statement on Broiler Chicken Welfare” in which it reports success in improvements but does not specify any breed changes.
There has been similar vagueness in the UK. Earlier this year, eighteen major restaurant chains, belonging to eight corporations, withdrew from the Better Chicken Commitment, instead joining a new industry-sponsored group called the Sustainable Chicken Forum. The main difference, the companies said, was that the industry-led group would not insist on a switch to slower-growing breeds.
That does not mean the Better Chicken Commitment has been abandoned. Tracey Jones, Compassion in World Farming’s global director of food business, points to the nonprofit’s annual ChickenTrack report from 2025, which found that more than 410 companies across Europe have adopted the Commitment, approximately twice as many as in the US, while three have fulfilled all commitments including slower-growing breeds. “Breed change is really the last thing to do,” Jones said.
Advocates admit progress has been slower than they once envisioned, something they attribute to several factors. Broiler welfare has multiple components, so it’s a complicated task to explain to food firms and their customers why they should back all of it. “With cage-free, it was relatively simple: Just get rid of cages for hens,” says Sharon Núñez, president of Animal Equality, one of the organizations that helped develop the Commitment ten years ago. “But this required more sophistication in terms of the language and what we were asking for.”
That can be construed, perhaps, as a demand problem: Because the Better Chicken Commitment asked companies to do several things, buyers—for households or companies—may be unsure about what to support in the marketplace. But there’s also a production-side problem. Look at the US companies that have backed the Better Chicken Commitment, and the issue becomes clear: Almost all of them are food-service or retail operations that agree to buy better chicken when it’s available in the market, while only five are producers who would grow that chicken if customers demanded it. Only one of the five—Perdue Foods, the fifth-largest broiler company in the US—could do it at scale. The others serve regional or specialty markets.
This poses a literal chicken-and-egg conundrum. Scaling production of any poultry variety requires years of preparation, breeding grandparent birds to hatch parent birds to hatch the broilers that companies would process and sell. “The producers don’t want to spend hundreds of millions of dollars to put better breeds on the ground and figure out the production changes that are necessary to raise birds with different genetics and process them, and then not have buyers for them,” deCoriolis says. “They need the commitments from the big buyers that have a huge amount of market leverage.”
That leaves advocates for better chicken suspended, for now, between hard things that have been accomplished and harder things that remain—a status they describe among themselves as “all but breed.”
The current American answer to the European better chicken—a bird that has space and freedom to exercise, can indulge its instincts, and is guaranteed the least painful slaughter method—may be growing right now in a field in central Georgia.
On a 1,300-acre farm, rows of steel-tubing coops, 50 feet wide and 150 feet long, are covered in white propylene and rigged inside with feeding systems and water lines that hang at the height of a chicken’s head. The coops have no flooring; instead, the six thousand chickens inside each coop peck and scratch and bed down on grass. Once each morning, while it is still cool, solar panels charge batteries that drive electric motors to move the coops’ lawnmower-sized tires. Each coop trundles exactly 50 feet to one side, matching the typical pace of an unstressed chicken, and the birds inside move with it, and settle down when it stops.
Frank Perdue, a former CEO of Perdue Farms, in 1982. Today, Perdue claims to be the world’s largest pasture-raised chicken company. Photo by Kevin Fleming/Corbis via Getty Images
This is the flagship location of Pasturebird, whose owners believe their company may be the world’s largest pasture-raised poultry producer. The company began as a backyard poultry operation fourteen years ago in California, and was eventually acquired by Perdue. It is not a pocket demonstration farm; this location raises over 100,000 birds per week, and the meat from those and from birds at a second property is sold nationwide through retailers including Sprouts Farmers Market, a natural and organic grocery chain.
What Pasturebird represents is how a poultry company that operates at scale—industry statistics from 2024 report that Perdue slaughtered almost twelve million birds per week—approaches the demands of the Better Chicken Commitment. Perdue was on the path to its own version of a better bird before that compact; in 2014, it shocked the US poultry industry by becoming the first large company to renounce routinely giving antibiotics to its chickens. Since then, it has improved diet and access to daylight, added enrichments, and increased available space for all its flocks, with Pasturebird, an entirely outdoor operation, being the most complete expression of that. Perdue has also changed its slaughter method. But it has not changed the breed it raises: Pasturebird and all Perdue’s flocks remain the white-feathered, feed-efficient hybrids that are the backbone of the global industry.
“I thought the Better Chicken Commitment was a decent approach because it said, This is what we think are the five biggest components to welfare. And we agreed on four of the five,” says Dr. Bruce Stewart-Brown, who retired as Perdue’s chief science officer in 2025. “The part that we weren’t totally in on is that it took breed to get you there.” The company ran a private experiment, raising parallel flocks of conventional and slower-growing birds to compare their metrics. Because the slower-growing breeds live longer and therefore eat more, “they will set you back in your carbon footprint,” he said. “So if you need to bring along your sustainability, you will go backward on the high-welfare breeds.”
Pasturebird was founded by Paul Greive, an accountant and former Marine who began raising slower-growing birds on grass in a quest for a cleaner diet, and then sold them to restaurants and online customers. In 2019, when Perdue bought Pasturebird, he stayed on to expand their pasture-based model. He argues that their operations actually go beyond the requirements of the Better Chicken Commitment, which does not explicitly call for outdoor access. He’d like to think they are honoring its spirit in ways the compact did not foresee.
“Fresh pasture loaded with bugs and worms, fresh air, the ability for a bird to hide inside of a big tuft of grass or to dust bathe—I would submit that is also an enrichment,” he says. “The idea of the BCC, why it was started, was to try to push the industry forward. Maybe what we’re doing is an even greater effort at the same goal.”
At this point, the landscape of chicken welfare in the US is uneven. Some big producers and food-service companies never cared to pursue improvements. Others made verbal commitments but have not disclosed their progress. Still others made good-faith efforts but stalled. And some, like Perdue, have taken a different approach altogether. This has led advocates into a period of reassessment and a debate about how to generate momentum without ignoring the progress that participants have achieved.
“It’s the enormity of what the BCC asks for that gives it the perception of failing,” says Matthew Dominguez, the US executive director for Compassion in World Farming. “It’s like, we wanted to get to Mars, but we’ve landed on the moon. But if our goal was the moon, we’d be celebrating that we were victorious.”
The complexities of the poultry supply chain, he acknowledges, are an enduring problem. The genetic recipes for most of the commercial broilers in the world, slow-growing or conventional, are controlled by only two companies— Aviagen and Cobb-Vantress, the final descendants of the businesses launched by Vantress and Saglio decades ago. Slow-growth is a niche product for them, which imposes limits on the available supply. The conditions also include the reality that most American consumers like chicken as it exists today: soft-muscled, tender after cooking, not highly flavored, lacking the tang and chew of a longer-lived bird.
And those complexities may pose more difficulty now because of the surrounding cost of living crisis, which makes it hard to ask either companies for more investment or consumers to spend more. “All but breed” may be where the conversation settles while the movement works on the commitment’s interim steps. But, looking forward, “I really do think that we can at least get a portion of the population to care enough to start shifting demand,” he says.
“If we get ten percent of the broiler industry to move on several key higher-welfare tenets of the Better Chicken Commitment, it would be one of the largest reductions of animal suffering in human history, when you’re looking at the number of animals affected. So, for us, it’s not about all or nothing. It’s about improving the lives of as many animals as we can, as we go.”
Help us keep digging!
FERN is a nonprofit and relies on the generosity of our readers. Please consider making a donation to support our work.
Cancel monthly donations anytime.

