Dianne’s Fine Desserts, of Newburyport, MA, is recalling 1,191 cases of its Cookie Butter Banana Pie because it contains undeclared almonds, a known allergen, not listed on the product label.
The outer carton is labeled “Cookie Butter Banana Pie,” while the inner carton is mislabeled as “Tropical Key Lime Pie.”
The recall, initiated on April 12, 2025, is classified as a Class II recall, indicating a low risk of serious health consequences, though temporary or reversible effects may occur. The recall remains ongoing, according to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
The recalled products were distributed to retail locations in Illinois, Oklahoma, New Jersey, South Carolina, New York, California, North Carolina, Washington, Iowa, Mississippi, Kansas, Florida, Tennessee, Nevada, Texas and Minnesota.
Recalled product:
Cookie Butter Banana Pie
Description: Outer carton labeled “Cookie Butter Banana Pie,” inner carton labeled “Tropical Key Lime Pie,” NET WT. 11 LB 2.8 OZ (5.06 kg)
Code Information: SKU #8495241471, Lot #6Z4L04, UPC: 767367101855, Expiration Date: 11/04/2025
Product Quantity: 1,191 cases (2 units per case)
Recall Number: F-0748-2025
As of the posting of this recall, no illnesses or adverse reactions have been reported in connection with this issue.
Consumers who have purchased the recalled Cookie Butter Banana Pie are urged not to consume it. The product should be discarded or returned to the place of purchase.
About food allergies
Almonds are a major allergen recognized by the FDA, and exposure can cause symptoms ranging from mild reactions, such as hives or itching, to severe anaphylaxis, a potentially life-threatening condition requiring immediate medical attention. Individuals experiencing adverse reactions after consuming this product should seek medical care promptly.
(To sign up for a free subscription to Food Safety News, click here.)
